# What If?: Serious Scientific Answers to Absurd Hypothetical Questions

Genres:

## Book Preface

This book is a collection of answers to hypothetical questions.

These questions were submitted to me through my website, whereâ€”in addition to serving as a sort of Dear Abby for mad scientistsâ€”I draw xkcd, a stick-figure webcomic.

I didnâ€™t start out making comics. I went to school for physics, and after graduating, I worked on robotics at NASA. I eventually left NASA to draw comics full-time, but my interest in science and math didnâ€™t fade. Eventually, it found a new outlet: answering the Internetâ€™s weirdâ€”and sometimes worryingâ€”questions. This book contains a selection of my favorite answers from my website, plus a bunch of new questions answered here for the first time.

Iâ€™ve been using math to try to answer weird questions for as long as I can remember. When I was five years old, my mother had a conversation with me that she wrote down and saved in a photo album. When she heard I was writing this book, she found the transcript and sent it to me. Here it is, reproduced verbatim from her 25-year-old sheet of paper:

Randall: Are there more soft things or hard things in our house?

Julie: I donâ€™t know.

Randall: How about in the world?

Julie: I donâ€™t know.

Randall: Well, each house has three or four pillows, right?

Julie: Right.

Randall: And each house has about 15 magnets, right?

Julie: I guess.

Randall: So 15 plus 3 or 4, letâ€™s say 4, is 19, right?

Julie: Right.

Randall: So there are probably about 3 billion

soft things, and . . . 5 billion hard things. Well, which one wins?

Julie: I guess hard things.

To this day I have no idea where I got â€œ3 billionâ€ and â€œ5 billionâ€ from. Clearly, I didnâ€™t really get how numbers worked.

My math has gotten a little better over the years, but my reason for doing math is the same as it was when I was five: I want to answer questions.

They say there are no stupid questions. Thatâ€™s obviously wrong; I think my question about hard and soft things, for example, is pretty stupid. But it turns out that trying to thoroughly answer a stupid question can take you to some pretty interesting places.

I still donâ€™t know whether there are more hard or soft things in the world, but Iâ€™ve learned a lot of other stuff along the way. What follows are my favorite parts of that journey.

randall munroe